Where to buy Thanksgiving Pies locally in Jersey City

Your Local Guide to Thanksgiving Pies in Jersey City

Whether you are hosting or heading to a Thanksgiving dinner as a guest, we know how essential dessert can be. But don’t fear; Jersey City’s bakeries which specialize in crafting homemade pies in various flavors and sizes, are here to help you! Therefore, we created this guide to help you find Thanksgiving pies.

Traditionally, pies during Thanksgiving are made from seasonal ingredients like pumpkins, pecans, and apples. These have become the quintessential dessert staples of the celebration. You can buy them from stores like Whole Foods, ShopRite, Stop & Shop, Target, Morten Williams, BJ’s Wholesale Club, and others. You can also get them from local bakeries and restaurants, many of whom have special Thanksgiving pre-order menus as well as from Farmers’ Markets in Jersey City.

Cafe Madelaine pies and tarts

34 Coles Street, Jersey City

Cafe Madelaine has Thanksgiving special tarts and pies. Place your order online now. Pickup is at 34 Coles Street in Jersey City.

Jane Doe

333 Newark Ave, Jersey City

Celebrate Thanksgiving with Jane Doe‘s handcrafted pies, made from scratch with the finest ingredients. Reserve yours today and bring home a taste of tradition with a special twist. Pies available include Apple Crumble Pie, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, and Pumpkin Pie with Candied Sunflower Seeds. $35 a pie. Limited orders are available.

Sage Eats Bakery Pie

485 Marin Blvd, Jersey City

A woman-owned business, Sage Eats has the perfect pies for Thanksgiving. They also have pastries, cakes, and breads for you to enjoy.

Cocoa Bakery

275 Grand Street/475 Central Ave, Jersey City, NJ, 07302

The Cocoa Bakery has the perfect variety if you have a sweet tooth. Not only do they have classic pies, but they also have some great gluten-free options. This year they will offer apple pie, apple crumble, pumpkin pie, sweet potato with meringue, and more. You can also order other desserts like their famous cakes, cookies, and truffles. Make sure to place your order ahead of time.

Jam Cakery Events

326 5th Street, Jersey City, NJ, 07302

Jam Cakery is an excellent option if you are looking for whole pies and cakes this Thanksgiving! They also purposefully accommodate different dietary restrictions. They have options like pumpkin marshmallow pies, pecans, maple pies, apple crumble pies and more. Diners can feel safe knowing that the food was prepared with care without sacrificing any of the tasty flavors or celebratory aspects of a holiday meal. They have a whole Holiday pastry menu.

Sugartown Bakery

437 Jersey Ave, Jersey City, NJ, 07302

Located in downtown Jersey City, this bakeshop specializes in custom cakes, macarons, mousses, cookies, and other desserts. Additionally, you can order custom cakes for any occasion, but they also offer a variety of pies for Thanksgiving. They have many options, including strawberry, raspberry, lemon meringue, coconut, sweet potato, apple, pumpkin, pecan, and more.

Monteleone’s Bakery

741 Newark Avenue, Jersey City, NJ, 07302

Monteleone’s Bakery in Jersey City has permanently closed.

This Bakery has been running for 60 years! Monteleone’s Bakery has been a staple of the Jersey City community. They have a ton of delicious baked goods but stop by to pick up a pie! Pie options like pumpkin, apple, lemon, key-lime, and more are available.

Salt + Seed 

210 Hudson Street, Jersey City, NJ, 07302

Salt+Seed is temporarily closed.

Salt + Seed is an excellent option if you want a vegan option. For the holidays, everyone’s seasonal favorite flavors are on offer, including an apple crumble and a pumpkin mousse. Preorders are required and can be placed via the restaurant’s website.

Dulce de Leche Bakery

376 Central Ave, Jersey City, NJ, 07037

This Argentinian Bakery is family-owned and offers a variety of traditional bakery foods. They are located in Jersey City Heights. Dulce de Leche Bakery will offer various delicious pies, from pumpkin to fresh apple crumble pie.

Scram 

61 Erie Street, Jersey City, NJ, 07302

Scram is a Charleston, South Carolina, food truck-turned-Jersey City bakery. They also have the most amazing baked goods and desserts that are a must-try. For Thanksgiving, Scram will offer pies and other treats via preorder. Choices include Apple Crisp Pie, Pumpkin Pie, and Honey Pecan Pie.

Cangiano’s

225 Pavonia Avenue, Jersey City, NJ, 07302

Cangiano‘s will offer delicious pies this Thanksgiving, including apple, blueberry, pecan, pumpkin, and more. They will also be offering other delicious gluten-free options.

Waffle It & Co.

210 Hudson St, Jersey City, NJ 07302 and 232.5 & Pavonia Avenue, Jersey City, NJ 07302 

Thanksgiving is near, and Waffle It & Co. is offering pies for Thanksgiving day. You would have to call them for details.

Carlo’s Bakery 

95 Washington Street, Hoboken, NJ, 07030

Carlos Bakery in Hoboken will have pies ready for you for Thanksgiving! Get your pumpkin, apple, or pecan fix available in-store or delivered right to your door! They also have many other options: apple crumb, pumpkin pie, blueberry, coconut cheese, chocolate pecan pie, and more, including a wide variety of cheesecakes.

Dolce & Salato

1101 Grand Street, Hoboken, NJ, 07030

This Hoboken Dolce & Salato bakery features many Italian-baked goodies, but they also have pies that are perfect for Thanksgiving. Make sure to preorder.

Old German Bakery

322 Washington Street, Hoboken, NJ, 07030

Old German Bakery is an authentic German bakery with great options for Thanksgiving pies. They have their famous German apple pie, peach yogurt pie, cheese crumb, plum crumb, apple crumb, and more.

Yuki’s Bakery

720 Monroe St Store – E101, Hoboken, NJ 07030

Yuki’s in Hoboken offers various pies, from apple, chocolate, pumpkin, and pecan maple pie for Thanksgiving. So make your Thanksgiving preorders now!

Local Farmers Markets

A local farmer’s market in Jersey City will offer a great variety of pies. So whether you are looking for a half pie or a whole pie, stop by one of the local farmer’s markets. Check our guide to them here.

Updated: November 2024